Gem City Insurance Exterior

​Gem City Mission Statement

“Gem City Insurance is a locally owned insurance agency located in Quincy, IL. Gem City Insurance has been serving our community since 2010 and striving to be the best. Here at Gem City insurance you’re not only taken care of as a client, but we see you as a person not a policy. Customer services is our number one goal and serving our community every day. Contact us for all insurance needs such as health, auto, life, home, and commercial. “

Either of our agents, David Cain or Blaise Haxel would be more than happy to help get you a free quote or answer any questions you may have. Our Business hours are, M-F 9am-4:30pm.

Office: (217) 214-0534
Fax: 217-214-0535

David Cain

David Cain

Owner & Agent
Cell: 217-242-3248 (in case of emergency)

David Cain, a Quincy native began his insurance career in 2005 as a Farmers Insurance agent. David and his wife Holly opened Gem City Insurance Agency in 2008, as an independent insurance agency, serving the Illinois, Iowa and Missouri area in home, auto, commercial and health and life insurance needs. David is active in his community and enjoys a wide variety of sports. He also enjoys watching and supporting his children in their local high school and collegiate sports programs. If you can’t reach David in the office, you can probably find him at Berrian or Upper Moorman Park playing pickleball.

Contact David Cain anytime during business hours, M-F 9am-4:30pm

Mary Ann

Mary Ann

Marketing and Business Development Director

Mary Ann O’Hara originates from upstate New York and has lived in Quincy since 1998.

She enjoys spending time with her children and grandchildren here along with her two dogs Ozzie & Bella.

Mary Ann is also mom to Reagan at the office and enjoys his company very much!

Contact Mary Ann anytime during business hours, M-F 9am-4:30pm

Blaise Haxel

Blaise Haxel

Agent and Partner
Cell: 217-257-4034 (in case of emergency)

Blaise is a lifelong Quincy resident, graduating from Quincy University with a degree in Management. He enjoys all sports and anything that has to do with competition. He joined Gem City Insurance Agency in the fall of 2019 and has been in the industry for 4 years. He is experienced in personal insurance such as Home and Auto, Life and Health Insurance, as well as Commercial lines.

Contact Blaise Haxel anytime during business hours, M-F 9am-4:30pm

Gem City Insurance Team

Who We Are

Gem City Insurance Agency has a direct contract with IMT, Travelers, Progressive, Foremost, and Mercury. We also have access to dozens of other companies through brokerage affiliations. Our goal is to provide customer satisfaction at an elite level, while making sure your assets are covered to the best of our abilities. We are experts in all areas of your insurance, whether it be your house, vehicle, or your business.

Gem City Insurance

(217) 214-0534



Monday – Friday 9:00am-4:30pm,
S & S Closed

    Let us help you!

    5 out of 5 star Facebook rating!

    Give a gift to yourself! Refer a friend and if they bring their home, auto, business or health insurance to Gem City Ins. We will send you $20 in local dining gift certificates.